• Folks, if you've recently upgraded or renewed your annual club membership but it's still not active, please reach out to the BOD or a moderator. The PayPal system has a slight bug which it doesn't allow it to activate the account on it's own.

Friend or Foe?

Pulled this guy off a piece of LR, he is red/brown with pink claw tips, slightly hairy.

I think it is a Red Mithrax but I am not sure. I dont think he is a Gorilla crab b/c he is not hairy enough, and his claws do not have black tips.

So should he stay or should he go?

crabpic4.jpg

crabpic3.jpg


crabpic2.jpg

crabpic.jpg
 
In most cases a hairy crab is a bad crab or at least not reef safe. I wouldn't chance it. I would put it somewhere like a QT tank until you can positively ID it. If it turns out to be harmless then i would keep it.

Harry
 
it's not a crab from the xanthidae family...(aka dark-finger crabs). As Dr. Ron Shimek would say - there are just too many to identify from that family and virtually impossible to identify given that most of the ones in our tanks are juveniles.

Regardless - it does look like the red mithrax - pretty common from the gulf of mexico tbs lr. It's too small at this stage to be of any real danger and even at a larger size - would really only be of risk to fish that inhabit similar locales (e.g. gobies). I know some folks like to have crabs in their tank- and given the size of this guy- I'd be inclined to say "it'll be fine". Personally I removed all the crabs save the porcelain ones from my tbs lr. They lived in the sump until i needed food for the mantis.
 
thanks guys! it may not come accross in the pics, but this sucker is pretty big! i havent decided what i am going to do with him yet. i put him in an area of my sump for the time being where he cannot escape.
 

Phyl

Officer Emeritus
Officer Emeritus
Emerald crab sized? Without the black tips, I wouldn't be too worried about it. It does look a lot like an emerald. The sump to eat the leftovers would be a good place if you're not comfortable with him in the tank.
 
I say banish the bugger!

At his size, I would label him a snail-muncher.

There's only a few crabs that are really reef-safe in the sense that they won't consume other creatures as well as not consume corals. I won't claim to be an expert on identifying them, but I've lost hundreds of $ in snails over the years to hitchhiker crabs. You've already got the bugger in hand, don't forget how tough it is to catch them.
 
Top