• Folks, if you've recently upgraded or renewed your annual club membership but it's still not active, please reach out to the BOD or a moderator. The PayPal system has a slight bug which it doesn't allow it to activate the account on it's own.

Bio Pellet Again

horseplay

NJRC Member
I'd like to get some opinion on how people run their bio pellet.

This is my second time running a BP reactor. I started running it about 2 months ago, when PO4 was 0.1. and I think sometime during last week PO4 is down to undetectable level. It shows zero on Hanna checker. Obviously it's impossible to have BP export matching exactly the PO4 output of the tank so either BP is taking out too much or not at all. Also note that I do see algae on the glass so there is nutrient in the water. I also feed quite liberally so there is always nutrient going thru the system. I see some very minor paling of the color of some of the SPS corals. I run the tank at 7.3 ALK.

So here are the options:

1. Remove some pellets but this will suffer from the problem mentioned above, either too little or too much pellets. Consider how slowly the PO4 decreased to zero the amount of BP is probably very close to the balance point.
2. Running the reactor part time. If this works it can give me a finer control on how much nutrients to remove. For example, I can run 50 minutes every hour this will keep the water in the reactor fairly fresh while reducing the amount of nutrients the reactor removes.
3. Do nothing and wait a few more weeks to see longer term effect.

I do measure nitrate weekly and if it becomes zero I dose 1ppm. Right now it's at 1ppm.

Like to hear some thoughts on this and how people run their reactors.
 
I know you asked about pellets but this is why I use red sea nopox with a doser. It allows me to exactly tune my phos and nitrate levels with carbon dosing. Maybe give it a look.
 

horseplay

NJRC Member
I know you asked about pellets but this is why I use red sea nopox with a doser. It allows me to exactly tune my phos and nitrate levels with carbon dosing. Maybe give it a look.

I have used nopox before I brought back the reactor. It was working great for a while with a low dosage (3ml for 200g water volume) but later on I could not keep the nutrient level down even with increased dosage, as high as 20ml daily. I started to think there was a bacteria die off in my tank. I never had this problem with BP. Also I had some Cyano problems with nopox that I never had with BP before.
 

redfishbluefish

Officer Emeritus
Officer Emeritus
Joe, I know you've probably already stated it on other posts, but my pea-brain can't remember.....what BP reactor are you running and how much BP's in there?

I think what I'd try first is reducing the amount of BP's.
 
I have used nopox before I brought back the reactor. It was working great for a while with a low dosage (3ml for 200g water volume) but later on I could not keep the nutrient level down even with increased dosage, as high as 20ml daily. I started to think there was a bacteria die off in my tank. I never had this problem with BP. Also I had some Cyano problems with nopox that I never had with BP before.
I dose my tank weekly with mb7 bacteria to avoid bacteria issues. I also dose nitrate to maintain the Redfield ratio so I can keep my phos low enough. Good luck.
 

horseplay

NJRC Member
Joe, I know you've probably already stated it on other posts, but my pea-brain can't remember.....what BP reactor are you running and how much BP's in there?

I think what I'd try first is reducing the amount of BP's.

I run a reef octopus BP110 with about 500ml of EcoBak pellets in it. 180g water volume medium stocked. Feed the tank the equivalent of 1 large cube of blackworm and some flakes daily.
 

horseplay

NJRC Member
I dose my tank weekly with mb7 bacteria to avoid bacteria issues. I also dose nitrate to maintain the Redfield ratio so I can keep my phos low enough. Good luck.

Thanks for the info. What I might be missing as part of the nopox regime was mb7. I remember reading about it but the dosing started working quite quickly so I never thought too much about it. I did dose nitrate as well to maintain the Redfield issue.
 
Top