• Folks, if you've recently upgraded or renewed your annual club membership but it's still not active, please reach out to the BOD or a moderator. The PayPal system has a slight bug which it doesn't allow it to activate the account on it's own.

Is my skimmer sufficient?

My parameters are always pretty much the same from month to month and are well within specs. My phosphates tend to get high at times. I've taken every measure in order to squash them...aint workin. The only thing I can think of is my skimmer. I skim wet and empty my cup every few days as it is really gross. The only thing I can think of is that my skimmer may not be sufficient. I also, keep a wad of poly filling in one of my baffles as a physical filtration and I replace it twice a week. Its a RO needle wheel 110. I have a 90g display and a 30g sump. I have a several small fish, not many. 2 clowns, 2 square anthias, goby & pistol, flame angel, damsel, and a banghaii card....8 small fish in a 90g. I am not sure if bumping up my skimmer to something larger if that would help. I've read in several other posts that by increasing their skimmer and or sump, it relieved their phosphates. Any ideas?
 
I think if I were looking to but a new one, I'd go with one that was a little larger. But if that one is in good working order, I don't know that I would change it. What else are you doing, i.e. GFO reactor for the PO4, GAC reactor, fuge?

PS What are your parameters?
 
High cap GFO in a TLF 150 reactor (changing every 3 days), fuge with chaeto....
I have healthy chaeto and a great piece of halimeda in the DT.

temp 80'
sg 1.025
calc 480
amm 0
ph 8.0
nitrite 0
nitrate 0
phosphate .41
kh 8 dkh

My MH's are on 3-4 hours a day and my T5 actinics are on about 9 hors a day. Feeding once a day with the food you gave me and some frozon plankton rinsed every other day. Could it be the poly-fil? I do change it twice a week. It does capture a ton of stuff. The HA isnt going crazy but it is keeping me very busy.
 
Wow, I can't imagine where your getting all that PO4 from. You do have a Hanna meter right? I'm using the high capacity GFO too, and only have to change it about every two months. How's your RO/DI unit?
 
Wow, I can't imagine where your getting all that PO4 from. You do have a Hanna meter right? I'm using the high capacity GFO too, and only have to change it about every two months. How's your RO/DI unit?
My TDS reads 004 and no PO4. I am stumped.
 

kschweer

Administrator
Staff member
Officer Emeritus
Moderator
Should be ok as per the manufactures specs. For what it's with I run a dnwb-110 on my 46g display with a 20g sump. It's the recirculating skimmer. And I am ordering the same one you have for my 30g frag tank with 15 gallon sump. The one I have works very well for me on my display system with tons of coral and 6 fish.
 
Has anyone ever heard of bumping your alkalinity to decrease HA growth? Personally, Ive never heard of it. Someone whos been in the biz for a very long time said, "if you increase your hardness or alkalinity you will pretty much stop the HA." Anyone heard of that? If so, please teach me what the chemical reason is.
 
Never heard of that, but you might also kill your SPS in the process. Doesnt sound like an experiment I would want to do. HA is from nutrients, fix the nutrients, HA goes away. Everything else is bandaids.
 

fatoldsun

NJRC Member
Has anyone ever heard of bumping your alkalinity to decrease HA growth? Personally, Ive never heard of it. Someone whos been in the biz for a very long time said, "if you increase your hardness or alkalinity you will pretty much stop the HA." Anyone heard of that? If so, please teach me what the chemical reason is.

I'm battling some HA too and I noticed doing my testing that my dkh jumped in the last week or two from the 7s up to 9.6. Now that might not be as high as was contemplated when you read that but I'll say that my increase was unintentional and it's had no impact on the HA. Maybe a dkh of 11-12 would be closer to what was suggested but I agree it would be bad for SPS. and here's an example where close to 10 had no impact on the HA
 
The advice was to increase my alk from 8/9 to 12 dkh. I dont get it, but he said it is all he has ever done in order to battle HA. Be reminded I live in SOUTH Jersey there is one store down here. The advice may have come from that store...it's been around forever.
 
The advice was to increase my alk from 8/9 to 12 dkh. I dont get it, but he said it is all he has ever done in order to battle HA. Be reminded I live in SOUTH Jersey there is one store down here. The advice may have come from that store...it's been around forever.
If the store you got your advice was in P'ville I wouldnt trust that advice.
 
Raising your dKH will not have any effect on hair algae - none. GAC, GFO, and lots of water changes are what most would likely recommend. If these methods fail, you may want to read up on lanthanum chloride. As mentioned above this is a nutrient issue. In terms of treating the symptoms, some have had success using Algaefix Marine. You may also want to ensure that your RO/DI is producing zero TDS. Good luck!
 
HA is under control with the introduction of GFO and increased water changes. Still have to pluck here and there but nothing worrying for me. Thanks downbeach for the advice, it all worked.
 

mnat

Officer Emeritus
Staff member
Moderator
The rock could possibly be leaching nitrates or phosphates out which is why you cannnot get your levels down.
 
The rock could possibly be leaching nitrates or phosphates out which is why you cannnot get your levels down.
Even though it's been over a year? Wow...I had no idea it could continue to leach for so long. I suppose it certainly could be the problem. But as I said earlier, it's seems to be much better and a bit more under control. Other than a little pickin here and there. As long as I run the GFO though. I am afraid to stop, in fact I dont find any reason to stop. Is there any harm in continually running GFO?
 
Top