• Folks, if you've recently upgraded or renewed your annual club membership but it's still not active, please reach out to the BOD or a moderator. The PayPal system has a slight bug which it doesn't allow it to activate the account on it's own.

Tank crashed!

I could be wrong but I think I read somewhere about possibly adding an acid to the water to help lower Alk. Possible Paul could chime in here.
Also adding calcium would also help to drive down Alk as well. Again maybe Paul could chime in.
But I would think freshly made saltwater would be higher in Alk making it tougher to bring down.
 

ecam

President
Staff member
Board of Directors
NJRC Member
Moderator
I could be wrong but I think I read somewhere about possibly adding an acid to the water to help lower Alk. Possible Paul could chime in here.
Also adding calcium would also help to drive down Alk as well. Again maybe Paul could chime in.
But I would think freshly made saltwater would be higher in Alk making it tougher to bring down.

John that would apply if you were taking the tank from 10 to 9.5 or something. But after a gallon of Alk i haveto assume that alk is the teens if not higher... so even getting the tank back to 10 would help (assuming thats the range of the salt mix)
 

Hockeynut

NJRC Member
Can I use a acid to drop alk like white vinegar?
Alk is at 19.6 after 50 gallons water change in a 100 gal volume
 
I tried to find the thread but no luck. It was not Vinegar though. I think the added carbon source could be a issues with that. Im sitting here at work trying to finde something though.
 

kschweer

Administrator
Staff member
Officer Emeritus
Moderator
So sorry to see this rob. I know how it feels. Please let me know if you need room for any livestock. My parents live up the road and my brother has a 120 reef there. I'm sure he will be happy to hold anything for you. Keep your head up it will look just as good if not better soon enough.
 

Hockeynut

NJRC Member
I tried to find the thread but no luck. It was not Vinegar though. I think the added carbon source could be a issues with that. Im sitting here at work trying to finde something though.
Thanks John


Thanks Kevin,
I think it is going to be a good reason to upgrade to the 120
 

Hockeynut

NJRC Member
Thanks everyone, I think I'm going to do it with water changes 95% of the coral that seems to have survived is in my sons tank so there isn't to much that can be affected so I'll let it drop slowly and see what happens.
I know I said it earlier but this club is great. All that have offered help and corals to replace some that were lost are awesome.

For all who just watch from the sidelines and don't become members, you are making a mistake, become members go to meeting and you will find friends who you didn't know and you will be better for it, that's all I will say on that:)
 

hcker99

Sponsor
Gold Sponsor
Thanks everyone, I think I'm going to do it with water changes 95% of the coral that seems to have survived is in my sons tank so there isn't to much that can be affected so I'll let it drop slowly and see what happens.
I know I said it earlier but this club is great. All that have offered help and corals to replace some that were lost are awesome.

For all who just watch from the sidelines and don't become members, you are making a mistake, become members go to meeting and you will find friends who you didn't know and you will be better for it, that's all I will say on that:)


Fixing it with water changes is definitely the right thing to do. Let me know if you need any help.
 
Sorry to read this just got online, I had same problem but with magnesium. Just did as much water changes as I could for a week. Lost a couple of SPS but that was it. I don't have a lot of corals right now (mostly small stuff) but your welcome to stop over sometime and frag off what you want. I am in levittown, almost a straight shot down 195.
 

iTzJu

Officer Emeritus
NJRC Member
Thanks everyone, I think I'm going to do it with water changes 95% of the coral that seems to have survived is in my sons tank so there isn't to much that can be affected so I'll let it drop slowly and see what happens.
I know I said it earlier but this club is great. All that have offered help and corals to replace some that were lost are awesome.

For all who just watch from the sidelines and don't become members, you are making a mistake, become members go to meeting and you will find friends who you didn't know and you will be better for it, that's all I will say on that:)

Rob any updates? hopefully its getting better, once im setup again, i can throw you some small frags.
 

Hockeynut

NJRC Member
Not much has changed ju what's lost is gone tank is pretty empty except for zoaanthids, palys, and mushrooms. Fish seem un affected, we will see what survives in Adams tank.

Thank you for offering Hans but it going to be a while before I start re stocking.

I'm still going to the swap on sat if for nothing just to hang out and see some of the guys, and gals and to help out.
 
Just saw this. Hope the other corals pull through. If anyone in my area is going to see Rob i can throw in a bag of RC salt good for 50 gals for your water change. Good luck!!
 
Just saw this. Hope the other corals pull through. If anyone in my area is going to see Rob i can throw in a bag of RC salt good for 50 gals for your water change. Good luck!!
+1 if anybody near me is going I can get Rob as much DI water as he might need.

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S5
 

Hockeynut

NJRC Member
Thanks guys I think I hav enough water and salt, I got the alk down to 14 today unfortunately most sps did not make it some lps should along with zoas and palys.

For all who are wondering how this might have happened. Here's how it went, I wasn't dosing any cal only small amounts of alk. I never test my water so a couple days ago I tested it because my color was a little weak. The test showed my cal was under 300 so I decided to dose a little cal so I set my doser to 10 Mils a day.
Unfortunately when I set it instead of hitting the auto option I hit the on option. Along with this and I don't know how once again I must have mixed up my alk and cal jugs so it dumped most of a gal of alk solution into the tank and by the time I realized what had happened alk was over 20.
Man when it rains it pours
 
Top