Don't kid yourself, we really are on a whole other planet out here, lol.
For tank bred fish and aquacultured corals, your best bet for something close by is gonna be the places along/near 22. There's a bunch of places along 78/22 like OGII in North Plainfield, Elos in Short Hills, Pet Shanty in Scotch Plains, there's more that I'm missing, but these are the 3 I've been to.
LOL! I have not checked out Pet Shanty yet. Elos sounds like a nice place. They'll probably be next on my scouting trip. I'm thinking its time to start branching out further into PA. I liked Something Fishy and The Hidden Reef looks like a nice place and its a shorter driver then going to Max Reef. I'm thinking I may go with aqua-cultured corals online. I've been looking at Tidal Gardens and Pacific East. Can't bring myself to order fish online. Too concerned about the added stress and potential DOAs.